Jump to content
🎄 🎄 🎄 2024 Custom Ornament Business Kit - Now Available - SALE 50% Off Through Dec. 2nd ×
Ornaments For Charity eBook - Designers Wanted! ​​​​​​​🙏 ×

Screws or Glue ( Clock Base's )?


kmmcrafts

Recommended Posts

Over the last couple years I have been making and selling quite a few desk clocks.. I have always used countersunk screws in the base to attach to the clock portion.. Recently I did a pattern that due to detail of the clock there was no place to put screws in that wouldn't pop through into the design. I glued the thing up with I think titebond II glue.. I somewhat liked the ease of just gluing it rather than setting up my drill press 2 times just to make the counter sunk screw holes.. ( they probably have special counter sinking bits don't they? ) 

 

Anyway talking long term... which is more durable and stronger?

 

I was never a big fan of gluing stuff.. but i have to say I was quite surprised how solid it felt.. got me to thinking that maybe the glue is stronger than the screws.. Considering I normally make my clocks out of 1/2" stock drill a hole in the center on each end and putting screws in it... it is only attached at two points.. unlike the glue attaching it the full length..

 

Anyway what are your thoughts on either?

 

Kevin 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Over the last couple years I have been making and selling quite a few desk clocks.. I have always used countersunk screws in the base to attach to the clock portion.. Recently I did a pattern that due to detail of the clock there was no place to put screws in that wouldn't pop through into the design. I glued the thing up with I think titebond II glue.. I somewhat liked the ease of just gluing it rather than setting up my drill press 2 times just to make the counter sunk screw holes.. ( they probably have special counter sinking bits don't they? ) 

 

Anyway talking long term... which is more durable and stronger?

 

I was never a big fan of gluing stuff.. but i have to say I was quite surprised how solid it felt.. got me to thinking that maybe the glue is stronger than the screws.. Considering I normally make my clocks out of 1/2" stock drill a hole in the center on each end and putting screws in it... it is only attached at two points.. unlike the glue attaching it the full length..

 

Anyway what are your thoughts on either?

 

Kevin 

 

Pin nails and glue is my favorite. In the beginning i just used drywall screws then i tried epoxy glue as it set up now. But use glue exclusively now.and rubber bands for clamps.

Edited by amazingkevin
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay thanks for the replies..

 

Now my next question....

 

Someone mentioned a "Good Glue" is stronger than screws or nails... So... what do you consider a good glue? or what is the glue of choice that you all use? I believe I used Tite Bond II.. 

 

Now I have had just one issue.. minor but non the less.. When gluing. I may on a couple occasions had the clock move from the base which got some glue on the top of the base.. I exclusively use beeswax and mineral oil mixture for my finishes and the areas that got the glue on them stood out like a sore thumb.. I hand sanded the glue off and it turned out fine.. however I do not like to re-sand a nice sanded smooth piece.. and getting up next the the joined pieces was somewhat difficult. What is your solution for this?

 

Maybe special type of glues or, be more careful LOL.. After doing a few like this I have become more careful and had decent results.. but I sort of feel as though I am not getting enough glue on there to adhere good.. though they do seem good and solid..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I use tightbond and it holds  every thing fine . I missed gluing a project last year an could not get the part apart . went on the internet and found out the only way to take it apart I h;ad to soak it in vinegar,I did this for about 21/2 hours and it came apart but the glue was still on the parts I had to scrape it off.  so when possible i glue 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A good glue joint requires some form of clamping. Rubber bands, binder clips, tape or pin nails can all be used to give some clamping pressure. 

 

For most desk clocks, even a bad joint will probably hold up for years. There isn't a lot of stress on most desk clocks, just occasionally lifting to dust underneath.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It would be interesting to see the joint that brought up this question!!

 

While I think wooden glue joints are strong I often re-enforce them with mechanical fasteners, as long as I can hide them.

 

I use Titebond II, Titebond molding glue, Rockler CA thin and medium, Loctite epoxy, and Elmer's white all purpose glue - it depends on the application.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally, I like to use screws, the reason I like to use screws is that it makes taking the clock apart easier. You never know when something will get broken, or need repairs. If it is glued together, there's little chance of taking it apart without causing more damage. I do use glue only in places, but, not usually when attaching a base to a top part. For gluing wood pieces together, I use Tite-Bond ll for most applications, but not all. 

Len

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay thanks for the replies..

 

Now my next question....

 

Someone mentioned a "Good Glue" is stronger than screws or nails... So... what do you consider a good glue? or what is the glue of choice that you all use? I believe I used Tite Bond II.. 

 

Now I have had just one issue.. minor but non the less.. When gluing. I may on a couple occasions had the clock move from the base which got some glue on the top of the base.. I exclusively use beeswax and mineral oil mixture for my finishes and the areas that got the glue on them stood out like a sore thumb.. I hand sanded the glue off and it turned out fine.. however I do not like to re-sand a nice sanded smooth piece.. and getting up next the the joined pieces was somewhat difficult. What is your solution for this?

 

Maybe special type of glues or, be more careful LOL.. After doing a few like this I have become more careful and had decent results.. but I sort of feel as though I am not getting enough glue on there to adhere good.. though they do seem good and solid..

Just take a damp cloth and thoroughly clean the glue off the wood before it dries. You will still need to do some light sanding to smooth the wood but it shouldn't show after finishing. I will even take a screwdriver and wipe the damp cloth right up next the the joint to get all the glue off the wood.  No need for special glue...any good wood glue.

Edited by EarltheScroller
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

Now I have had just one issue.. minor but non the less.. When gluing. I may on a couple occasions had the clock move from the base which got some glue on the top of the base.. I exclusively use beeswax and mineral oil mixture for my finishes and the areas that got the glue on them stood out like a sore thumb.. I hand sanded the glue off and it turned out fine.. however I do not like to re-sand a nice sanded smooth piece.. and getting up next the the joined pieces was somewhat difficult. What is your solution for this?

 

I think it depends on the project... I know lots of folks use a damp cloth to wipe off glue when it weeps out of joints but I  no longer do that. It raises the grain and certainly causes additional sanding. (Although I normally sand before and after assembly.) Because polyurethane glues are water soluble, wiping with a damp rag can allow moisture to penetrate and weaken the glue joint. Finally, many times it's difficult wipe down joints with all the clamps in place. 

 

Now I wait about 1/2 hours, take off the clamps and use a paint scraper and dull chisels to remove glue while it's 'dry' but still soft. Another approach I use is to apply painters tape on surfaces that I know will get squeeze-out. Lot's of work but there's no extra sanding either.

 

As they used to say on Laugh-in, "different strokes for different folks".

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some people doubt the durability and strength of a glue joint. I submit that this project shows how strong, durable and long lasting today's glues are.  I joined two 1/2' poplar boards to make this trivet, I think it's from 1986. This trivet is in daily use and has be hand washed dozens of times. It's stained with Minwax, there is no top-coat of any kind.

 

There are two pics, one from each side. The joint is much more noticeable on the one side, no doubt from some mistake on my part.post-18045-0-10607000-1450216452_thumb.jpgpost-18045-0-73561000-1450216468_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...