Jump to content
🎄 🎄 🎄 2024 Custom Ornament Business Kit - Now Available - SALE 50% Off Through Dec. 2nd ×
Ornaments For Charity eBook - Designers Wanted! ​​​​​​​🙏 ×

Return or Keep?


Recommended Posts

My husband bought me a new 16" Master Mechanic for my birthday last week and it has been a pain.  First, the cam screw came flying out after about 5 minutes. Three times.  I used some thread locker and it's been okay since, BUT I decided I wanted to up my skills and do some inside cuts.  I bought some plain blades (the saw only came with pin ends) and thought it was going to be a breeze to install with the screw assemblies. It wasn't.  First of all, the upper blade holder is nothing like the one pictured in the manual.  After some thought I figured it out and guess what?  The blades are too short.  The original holder looks like it was attached to the bottom of the upper arm, this one is on top and looks like a sewing machine foot.  I was thinking about getting an adapter, but they attach to the front and I'm undecided as to whether it would make the reach.  With the bare minimum in the screw assemblies, it's about 3/8" shy of sliding in, even with the tension completely off.  So, after all that I was wondering if anyone had any ideas or should I return it and look for something else?I'd appreciate any input.

 

Update: Got up this morning and my husband had already returned it and ordered a 16" General International to replace it.  I hope this is a better one.  :)  Fingers crossed!

Edited by debinoz
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Doesn't sound like you were a "happy scroll sawer", and wise to return that Master Mechanic item. Do consider an up grade on a better brand quality name that you will be able to get parts, service, and have more "fun" in doing your SS projects. Go on line, read reviews, check $ (your budget & local stores) - THEN decide. Be safe. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Take it back! They are nothing but trouble! Good to hear he took it back. For a few $$$ more, you can invest in a better quality saw that does ALOT more, a better job of cutting, easier to operate, & no grief from the saw. Check out the reviews & read up to see which saw might suit your budget, & your purpose. You'll be happier in the end.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to the Village Debi! Nothing worse than trying to work with an inadequate tool. Your hubby did the right thing by taking it back. The General Excalibur EX 16 is a superior saw and it should serve you well!

Make sure you post pictures of your completed projects, so come on in and join the fun!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It all doepends on how much you have to inves in a saw. If you budget only allows about $100 then I think I would recommend the Ryobl. It will take both kind of blades and is verible speed, which is a good thing in a saw. I started with that saw and it served me well.

The parts are I not high quality but they are cheap to buy and easy to replace. If you have a $200 budget then I would suggest you go on Craigslist in your area and see if you can find a used better saw like maybe a DeWalt. It has a normal new price of around $600. If your budget is around $800 then the choice is finding the saw the you enjoy using most. You can then have about any saw out there. If that is the case, then I would suggest you go to different tool stores that sell those different saws and sit down for a demonstration and some hands on use. That way you will understand the top end saws and know which y out like best.

 

 

Dick

heppnerguy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trying to start out on a "bad" saw will ruin the pleasures that await you. I'm guessing you have learned that much so far. So .. welcome to the village.Scrolling should be a pleasure and not a heart ache. Craigslist is a hgood place to find a decent used saw. Ask before you buy, many can give you feed back. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My husband bought me a new 16" Master Mechanic for my birthday last week and it has been a pain.  First, the cam screw came flying out after about 5 minutes. Three times.  I used some thread locker and it's been okay since, BUT I decided I wanted to up my skills and do some inside cuts.  I bought some plain blades (the saw only came with pin ends) and thought it was going to be a breeze to install with the screw assemblies. It wasn't.  First of all, the upper blade holder is nothing like the one pictured in the manual.  After some thought I figured it out and guess what?  The blades are too short.  The original holder looks like it was attached to the bottom of the upper arm, this one is on top and looks like a sewing machine foot.  I was thinking about getting an adapter, but they attach to the front and I'm undecided as to whether it would make the reach.  With the bare minimum in the screw assemblies, it's about 3/8" shy of sliding in, even with the tension completely off.  So, after all that I was wondering if anyone had any ideas or should I return it and look for something else?I'd appreciate any input.

 

Update: Got up this morning and my husband had already returned it and ordered a 16" General International to replace it.  I hope this is a better one.   :)  Fingers crossed!

I too learned the hard way but stuck with it.I used el cheap-o saws for years not knowing there was better.Someone had a DW788 on craigs list so i went to try it.Seemed a step up.he wanted $200. and i told him i didn't have that kind of money but he was interested in trades.Ok ! i brought my 10"wide 4' long telescope on a stand thats tracks as the earth turns ,i kind of liked it but said no. I went home and grabbed all  of my practice intarsias.That flipped his wig alright and immediately shook my hand ,WE GOT A DEAL! He wanted the telescope too. no big deal i didn't want it anymore and i paid $500.00 for it.When i got it home i set it up and turned it on .waiting for it to start i noticed it was running silent as a j -bird.Wow this is a saw.Changing the blades was a pleasure too as the top arm raises way up so you can thread the blade easy in your project.That was the first of 8 dw788's i owned i gave the first one to my friend and he's still using it i gave him 2 cheapys before and he was not happy .I like having back up saws,lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks everyone for the replies and welcomes.  I had a very limited budget of $130.  I have a week to "stew" about it before it arrives.  My next challenge is going to be finding some wood to use.  The local lumberyard doesn't carry thin hardwoods and only plain plywood.  The closest Home Depot is about 35 miles away.  I had my son drive me over there and they had 2 half sheets of 1/4 plywood in their "craft" section and it wasn't cheap.  Even though things seem to be working against me, I am not giving up!  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have often wondered how many prospective scroll sawers were completely turned off by using a lousy scroll saw.   I can't for the life of me understand why some tool company can't come up with an entry level scroll saw that is more user friendly and will hold together at least long enough for a person to find out if they really like the hobby. 

 

My suggestion would be is to wait until you can afford a better quality good used scroll saw.

Edited by stoney
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The new saw came late yesterday and I thought I'd give my impression of it so far.  It's sure is purdy. Bright red and shiny.  The reason I mention that is because it reminds me of one of those old International tractors.  We used to call them "popcorn machines."  That is exactly what this thing sounds like.  It has a bit of a vibration, but it hasn't been bolted down yet.  I'm hoping that will make a difference.  On the downer down side, the blade holders are plastic.  Also there is no set screw, just the one for clamping the blade to the far side of the plastic.  The ends of the blade get bent and after about a dozen switches, the blade snaps.  I'm wondering how long it will take to wear a groove in there until eventually it won't hold a blade.  Also there is only the knob tension on the back, so there's a lot of knob twisting involved.  On the up side, it cuts really nice.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hate to tell you this but if you get more than 8-10 hours of actual cutting time consider that GOD has blessed you with a miracle. Since the blade holders are plastic the holding screws will strip out the soft threads. Breaking blades are often a sign of to little tension. Bending the blades at the top or bottom are often an indication that the blades holders are not in proper alignment. Since you said there are no set screws you can't align the blades.

 

I hate being so negative but send it back and wait until you can afford a better saw.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I totally agree with Stoney.!  It was wise to return it. I looked it up and saw a 1 star rating.

Good luck with your new saw, it is a great hobby shame to spoil it with a crappy saw.

I tend to be a spontaneous buyer, not always a good thing. I would come home with something less than what I wanted and end up buying the one I wanted later on.

Now if I want something I put money in my "toy fund" until I have enough for what I want. All of my fair money goes in the kitty only to be used for toys and other hobby related stuff. The rest is patience.

Now all I need is more space. :roll:

Edited by Rolf
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Returning this one too, if they'll take it.  The blade bit a little into the cover so we'll see.  The reason for the return? Some new developments:  It completely stalls out on the lowest speed and if you turn it up to about 1/3 power the speed is not constant, on high something really starts banging like the blade arm hitting the housing. Also there's the problem of the blade holders not being even you get a "ghosting" of about 1/2". I guess I'm done for now :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...