Opinions Please

[Dave Monk]

I am facing my biggest challenge so far as a scroller and designer.......but I love it. I am struggling with the black cat. Do you think I should leave the white off it's back..........I'm trying to resemble the picture. Please........I would love comments and criticisms on my pattern so far. Thanks, dave

[Birchbark]

I like it as is Dave.  The white spot under his chin will be a challenge maybe.  But for an all black cat, that's a very good pattern IMO. 

 

Russell

[Dave Monk]

Thank you Russell. I respect an oppinion coming from one of the best. My wife is very critical of my work so l appreciate any comments. dave

[rdatelle]

Dave, I kinda like the all black with the white under the chin. Seems like to much white on the back. I'm sure anything you do will be great.

[Rob]

Is the light grey on it's back just the light falling on it or is the cat really that colour?  I would go with less on the back and see how it looks.  You could always add more later.

 

Rob

 

P.S.  I'm not a pattern designer so what do I know!

[Debi Shipman]

I think it needs a little less white.  Maybe not as far along the top ridge. I'm sorry to say it sort of looks like a skunk instead of a cat.  :(

[amazingkevin]

way better than what i could come close to doing

[lawson56]

I have to agree with the skunk,other than that it looks Great,  Working with all Black has always been a Big Challenge.

[Gordster]

Looking good Dave...I would try a smaller highlight lines on the back of the black cat and add more as needed.

[Dave Monk]

I sure appreciate the comments. Last night I emailed the lady a price quot,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,so I might not have to do any more work on it. We'll seed. dave