Candle Holders

[edward]

This is a Steve Good project the one on the left is the original done on 1/4"BB and the right one is done on 1/8"BB which I made a couple changes, I sorta like the  one on the right, what do you guys think.

[FrankEV]

Both are nice, but do agree the one on the right is a little more pleasent to look at.  More delicate,  but I'm not sure removing the chimney completely is the best way.

Did you fix the problem with the top being loose. The ring makes it inviting to think it could be hung.   

I think I probably could come up with a way to make the bottom removable for replaceing the candle .  Then the top could be fixed/glued to the top of the walls so it could be hung. 

BTW, the workmanship is well done.

 

[lawson56]

I do like the Right better. I had thought of cutting that pattern myself. Awesome job on both.

[edward]

The top comes off, maybe the next one I may make the top perminant .

[Frank Pellow]

I prefer the one on the left.

I made two of these lanterns and talked about them them in the thread: Candle Lantern designed by Steve Good - Bragging Rights - Scroll Saw Village

Steve's plan did not have a mechanism for attaching the lid.  If you look at my thread you will see two different methods for attaching and removing the lid described and shown.

Edited May 8, 2021 by Frank Pellow

[Rockytime]

Great looking little lanterns, at least what I think of them as. I like both of them. You did a great job!

[wombatie]

I actually like both.  You did a great job on them.

Marg

[barb.j.enders]

Great job on both.  My preference is the one on the right.

[daveww1]

I also like both of them

[Tomanydogs]

I like them both. But I prefer the one cut from 1/4 bb ply the thicker wood appeals to me more. Well done. 

[young ned]

Both  are well cut